Mine was between Jennifer Love Hewitt and Sarah Michelle Gellar. I will make a list of who I think you crushes might have been : Jennifer Love Hewitt Sarah Michelle Gellar Salma Hayek Alyssa Milano Lorraine Bracco Linda Cardellini Jessica Alba Megan Fox Kristen Bell Halle Berry Alicia Silverstone Mila Kunis Tiffani Amber Thiessen Shannen Doherty Julie Benz Lauren Graham Minka Kelly Kerry Washington Charisma Carpenter Natalie Portman Gillian Anderson Rose McGowan Rachel McAdams Lindsay Lohan Angelina Jolie Jennier Aniston Reese Witherspoon Busy Phillipps Katie Holmes Winona Ryder Katherine Heigl Kristin Kreuk Sophia Bush Mischa Barton Holly Marie Combs Alyson Hannigan Michelle Williams Blake Lively Alexis Bledel Rachel Bilson Neve Campbell Amanda Seyfried Jennie Garth Monica Bellucci Erica Durance Keri Russell Daniel Fishel Evangeline Lilly Courney Cox Brooke Shields Drew Barrymore Eliza Dushku Kirsten Dunst Teri Hatcher Emma Waston Kate Winslet Scarlett Johansson Kristen Stewart Pamela Anderson Eva Longoria Leighton Meester Connie Britton submitted by /u/James-Samuel17
Originally posted by u/James-Samuel17 on r/AskMen