Something that always bothered me was that only the combat guilds have an associated quest with them. All of the other skilling guilds have a level requirement but once youre inside the guild theres really nothing going on except a more efficient skilling option. It makes each guild feel flat and unfinished. Take the fishing guild for example, you unlock the guild and now you can fish lobsters and sharks by a bank and thats sort of it. What if when you unlock the fishing guild, you unlock the guild quest. It doesnt have to be a huge grandmaster quest, the quest would be about the same difficulty as the champions guild quest. For example the guild master sends you on a quest to find a rumored rare fish and you have to track the location, and fish some fish along the way in different areas before finding this rare fish and brining it back to the guild. The requirements would be mainly just that skill and a couple extra mid level skilling stats. As a reward you get a bunch of fishing xp, and some qol fishing gear. For example a lucky fishing amulet that increases the chance of fishing fish by an extra 2.5% and increases the chance of finding a big fish by 5%. The idea is that theres an actual interaction with the guild after you meet the requirements for entry. So that the guild has a life, and a purpose outside of just efficient skilling xp. Also in a game of quests with so many different adventurers, theres entire guilds with no quest lines? That doesnt really make sense You could even have an entry quest, and also a mastery quest, where once you hit 90 you can take on a harder quest that really hones in the skill and makes you feel like you accomplished what that skill has to offer. These quests would be heroes quest level and would require a mix of other skills and combat levels. Still, just a thought, as some people probably wouldnt like the idea of the quest cape being locked behind high skilling stats when the diary cape exists. Thoughts? submitted by /u/PermissionTrue7924
Originally posted by u/PermissionTrue7924 on r/2007scape