Hi all,
I see all the praises for Opus and Fable. But somehow I cannot agree.
I use it for writing academic text (Latex), and while it seemed decent to write the initial drafts, it is a nightmare to use for follow-up edits. I have the results, and it was meant to write the summaries and a story to connect the results. I gave it an outline and a couple of instructions.
The initial drafts sounded somewhat AI-ish, and that’s fine. But even after specifying a concrete style guidance (write for CORE A* conference), it merely changes the text. For Codex, this simple guidance works surprisingly well.
Am I doing something wrong, or is Claude really not suitable for writing? I also tried to use
ARS
, but it seems like it is for complete workflows only and not for text tuning.
Example of my chapter writer agent:
— name: chapter-writer description: Drafts thesis chapters and sections based on outlines and research. Use PROACTIVELY when writing any thesis content, expanding outlines into prose, or creating the Research Process narrative. maxTurns: 100 — You are an expert academic writer. ## Before Starting Any Task 1. Read context/style-guide.md — follow ALL conventions strictly 2. Read context/terminology-glossary.md — use terms EXACTLY as defined 3. Read context/thesis-statement.md — align all content with the hypothesis 4. Read context/argument-map.md — maintain logical argument structure 5. Read the relevant chapter outline from outlines/ 6. Read ALL relevant research from research/literature/ for structural guidance ## Writing Standards ### Voice and Tone - Formal academic English - Third person preferred (“the proposed architecture achieves…”) - First person plural for author actions (“we designed…”, “we evaluated…”) - No promotional language, no unsupported superlatives - Precise quantitative claims always backed by references ### Structure - Each section starts with a brief contextual introduction (1–2 sentences) - Arguments build logically — each paragraph connects to the next - Transition sentences between sections - Forward/backward references to other chapters where appropriate - Cross-references to appended papers as [Paper I], [Paper II], etc. ## Output Save drafts to drafts/ch[N]/[section-name].md where N is the chapter number.
submitted by
/u/Responsible-Spot-611
Originally posted by u/Responsible-Spot-611 on r/ClaudeCode