They need to rethink how it rolls agaisnt neutral defence npcs. In its current state it performs just like the spicy tzhaar shit it looks like. With the current proposal scythe will be Slash BIS Neutral BIS by 21-22% over new mega Crush 2nd BIS in most places This makes the new weapon incredibly niche. Tob/Toa/colo no use cases, Cox tekton only with breaker being worse dps than tent whip on olm. The “Tzhaar Breaker” wont even be useful for fight caves/inferno/tzhaars lmao Even many of the actual use cases are bad on a second glance. This weapon should be OP considering it requires the equivalent of addy armour with negative slash/stab bonuses. You’ll probably lose dps chugging brews vs fang/masori at nex. No sensible person is going to use this over tbow at doom. It wont be worth wasting invy slots on inq swaps for CMs as its bad everywhere but tekton That leaves Cerb, Araxxor, Maggot King, Nightmare as the only real higher level pvm use cases. Scythe is already really good at these places. They either need to change the calcs or give it a stab option so mega rares cover slash/crush and crush/stab. submitted by /u/cabbagez
Originally posted by u/cabbagez on r/2007scape
